Online Book Communities are a great way to keep track of what you're reading and what others are reading. This was my first time actually exploring into one of these websites. I already had a
Goodreads profile, but I wouldn't keep up with it. I had somehow signed up through my Facebook account without even knowing about it. I like the concept of having virtual shelfs and being able to keep track of what I'm reading. Adding my books caused me to reflect on the books I have read. By the time I created my last account on
Booklikes, I was remembering more of my favorite books to add on my shelfs. I also like that I can share with others what I am reading and find out what they are reading. Its not every day you have time to ask someone in person about what they're reading. So this is awesome. I liked that in some of these websites you can create a blog.
I will now share my experience with each website, which websites I will recommend and which one I will more than likely continue using.
Goodreads Profile
My overall rating is 4.5/5
Goodreads Experience:
Goodreads is very easy to use. I love that it has the book cover icons to make it more visually appealing. It's simple and has just what I believe a book community should have; collections, recommendations, friends, and discussions. I like that the my friends activity as well as mine is on the front page.I like that my bookshelfs are on the front page shelved according to topics, genres or any tags I thought could describe the ideas of the book.
Advantages:
-easy access to shelves
-feature shelf has book covers
-sharing and recommending books with friends on Facebook, Twitter, Gmail, & Yahoo
-books can be exported to another website
-easy shelving process
-track what you and others are reading
-a look at new releases in every genre
-join groups or book clubs
-share quotes, comments & discussions
-mass or batch editing
Disadvantages:
-No blog
Student Interest:
-user friendly
-students can connect through Facebook or Twitter
-will recommend to students
Library Thing Profile
My overall rating is 3.5/5
Library Thing Experience:
This was the second website I explored. I immediately liked that it was able to import my books from
Goodreads because it saved me time. At first glance I thought it appeared kind of dull looking and too much text was unpleasing to the eye. I expect more visuals for book recommendations. I did however like that the Authors tab had a picture view. It was nice to be able to see the authors of my favorite books. I did not like that it contained "collections" and "tags" in which to categorize my books. I think that having either one would work for me, preferably tags serving as shelfs or collections serving as shelfs. Just one would be best to simplify things.
Advantages:
-recommendation list has no book cover icons just titles and authors
-love the author pictures tab
-Talk tab is very informative
-I think the "collections" are equivalent to the "shelves" on Goodreads.
-tags in Library Thing are simply labels topics.
-easy to import files from another online book website.
Disadvantages:
-not very appealing; dull
-recommendation list has no book cover icons just titles and authors
-doesn't have a mass or batch edit button that would make tagging easier.
-I don't see the reason for having both collections and tags.
-overload of text features doesn't make it user friendly
Student Interest:
-not very much visual appeal
-students might not be attracted to the text, tabs and a lot of information
-probably will not recommend to students
Shelfari Profile
My overall rating is 4/5
Shelfari Expience:
At first glance of this website, the profile page itself is more colorful with the tabs. I liked the visual appeal with the virtual shelf. The shelfs are easy to access and viewers could easily view your rating of the books which is a big help. I liked that the shelfs were on the front page and so were my tags. I didn't like that my Friends' activity tab, which is something that I look into often was not on the front page. I like to have all the basic features altogether for some reason. I don't think this takes away from the website itself, but for my personal choice it does. I like that you can create a blog, but again the access tab is too much clicking for me. You must find it under the Community tab. I like that you can see the book information when you move the mouse over the book covers. I also like the tag suggestion list that makes it a lot easier to tag books.
Advantages:
-love the visuals of shelves and books. It is very appealing compared to Goodreads and Library Thing.
-tag suggestions make it easier to tag
-standing over the book icon lets you see the book information such as tags, publication year, author and rating.
-friends' activity is not on the front page view. It's accessible by clicking the tab. I like how Goodreads has it available on the front page, simply scroll down.
- you can create a blog
Disadvantages:
-too many tabs to access basic features
Student Interest:
-students can invite friends from Facebook, Twitter, Gmail & Yahoo
-visually appealing
-will recommend to students to give them options
Booklikes Profile
My overall rating is 5/5
Booklikes Experience:
I like that it has all the basic features and more. Users can create a blog and the necessary tabs are on the profile page making it easy to access. It is definitely visually appealing with the book cover icons. the front page has my shelfs, blog and timeline tabs. I thought it had many features and tabs and I really had to play around with it to get the hang of it. Just getting to import books was a little hard for me to navigate. I wonder if students might have the same experience. Even though I had a little trouble, I believe I just need more time getting used to it. I think this is the online book community that I will continue using. Although I might suggest
Goodreads to my students to get them started.
Advantages:
-blog
-virtual book shelf
-visually appealing
-easy to access shelfs
-dashboard feature
-basic features
-imports shelfs from Goodreads, Library Thing, Lovely Books & Lubimy czytac
Disadvantages:
- too many features may be overwhelming for first time users
Student Interest:
-blog
-basic features
-visually appealing
-will recommend to students as an advanced option
Overall
I think all of these websites are great. Some are more appealing to young readers and so because of that, I believe that
Goodreads will be my number one recommendation for students. It's user friendly and has all the basic features to keep track of your reading and communicate with others. However, for my own book tracking I will continue using
Booklikes. I have explained the reasons why I won't recommend it to a student above. I plan to continue exploring it to become more familiar with it and learn to navigate it with ease. This was a great experience and hope to continue learning more about technology in general.